Thanksgiving Menu

Sugar Mama's Thanksgiving Menu

Southside and Eastside will both be hosting this special Thanksgiving menu in lieu of our everyday offerings 11/21 - 11/22

Pies


  • Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Our delicious chocolate pecan pie made with Texas-borne nuts and Kentucky bourbon Taking orders until 11/19/17 for pickup on Tuesday the 21st or Wednesday the 22nd! Secure your Thanksgiving pie!

  • Chocolate Cream Pie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Chocolate cream filling in a flourless chocolate cookie crust, topped with whipped cream and crushed toffee! Taking orders until 11/19/17 for pickup on Tuesday the 21st or Wednesday the 22nd! Secure your Thanksgiving pie!

  • Classic Pumpkin Pie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Traditional pumpkin pie with maple vanilla bean whipped cream. Taking orders until 11/19/17 for pickup on Tuesday the 21st or Wednesday the 22nd! Secure your Thanksgiving pie!

  • Lemon Buttermilk Pie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Our twist on a sweet southern delight. Buttery pie crust filled with a creamy buttermilk custard, topped with a layer of our housemade lemon curd. Garnished with fresh whipped cream and tart lemon zest. Taking orders until 11/19/17 for pickup on Tuesday the 21st or Wednesday the 22nd! Secure your Thanksgiving pie!

  • Praline Apple Pie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Granny smith apples tossed with brown sugar, caramel and Texas pecans in between two layers of buttery pie crust. Not your ordinary apple pie and sure to impress! Taking orders until 11/19/17 for pickup on Tuesday the 21st or Wednesday the 22nd! Secure your Thanksgiving pie!

Cupcakes


  • Back to School Special

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    A decadently dark chocolate cake filled with fresh whipped cream, topped with rich chocolate ganache and finished off with a curly q swirl.

  • Champion Carrot Cake

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    The winning recipe from our carrot cake contest! Carrot cupcake chock full of golden raisins, Texas pecans, pineapple and organic carrots + vanilla cream cheese frosting = a winning combination.

  • Cookies N' Cream (V)

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Our vegan Cookies N' Cream is a major hit! Bensdorp chocolate cake with bits of cream-filled chocolate cookies, topped with a vanilla frosting with even more cookies!

  • Cowboy (V)

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Vegan Valrhona chocolate cake filled with whipped peanut butter cream and topped with chocolate frosting and a peanut butter glaze. Non vegans will love this, too!

  • Harlow's Honey Baklava

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    One of our Cupcake Wars awards winners! Buttermilk honey cake made with Round Rock honey, baklava filling, cinnamon buttercream and topped with a filo puff.

  • Jack's Lemon

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Moist lemon cupcake topped with tangy lemon buttercream and a sour lemon candy. Pucker up, buttercup!

  • James Brown

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Moist Valrhona chocolate cupcake topped with rich chocolate buttercream and festive sprinkles. You'll feel good!

  • Marilyn Monroe

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    The original blond bombshell - buttery vanilla cupcake topped with luscious Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla buttercream. Happy birthday, Mr. President!

  • Mint Chip

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Dark chocolate cake wearing a hat of peppermint buttercream swirled with semisweet chocolate chips!

  • Mud Pie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    This one should bring you back. Valrhona chocolate cake covered in whipped espresso buttercream frosting, crushed chocolate cream sandwich cookies, fresh whipped cream, and a drizzle of dark chocolate syrup.

  • Plain Jane

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Don't be fooled by her name, this beauty sports a complex Valrhona chocolate cake and our famous vanilla buttercream. She's simple, she's sassy, she's amazing.

  • Salty LuLu

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Delicious orange cake topped with salted caramel buttercream and fleur de sel.

  • Southern Belle

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Ravishing red velvet cupcake topped with our irresistible vanilla cream cheese frosting.

  • Strawberry Shortkick

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Pink strawberry pound cake topped with an kickin' strawberry buttercream!

  • The Great Pumpkin

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Spiced pumpkin cake studded with mini semi-sweet chocolate chips, topped with our tangy cream cheese frosting!

  • The Great Pumpkin (V) (GF)

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Our monthly special made with gluten free and vegan ingredients!

Cookies


  • Everything Cookie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    What happens when you cross a peanut butter, oatmeal, and chocolate chip cookie? The Everything Cookie!

  • Frosted Sugar Cookie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    A delicious cream cheese sugar cookie topped with our vanilla buttercream frosting.

  • Iced Molasses Cookie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Best Overall Cookie winner in the 2010 Kookie Cookie Cookoff! Spicy molasses cookie topped with a delicious sugar frosting.

  • Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Buttery, delicious cookie riddled with Guittard milk chocolate chips.

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Naturally gluten free, this cookie is a wholesome mix of peanut butter, sugar, chocolate chips and love!

  • Salted Caramel Snickerdoodle

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Traditional snickerdoodle with a Sugar Mama's twist, filled with salty caramel and dusted with fleur de sel

  • Texican Wedding Cookie

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    We've added Texas pecans to traditional Mexican wedding cookies. This is easily Steve's favorite cookie!

Bars


  • Lemon Bar

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    A luscious layer of creamy lemon custard atop a thick and buttery shortbread crust.

  • Mint Chocolate Chip Bar

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Rich chocolate brownie layered with creamy mint filling, finished off with a dark chocolate glaze.

  • S'Mores Bar

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Graham cracker crust, a thick layer of creamy dark chocolate and a delicious pillow of house-made toasted marshmallow. You'll camp out for this one!

Other Sweets


  • Cookie Sammich (V)

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Our vegan buttercream frosting smashed between two huge dark chocolate chip vegan cookies.

  • Macaron

    : Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa

    Our creative team of baker's are always coming up with new ideas for our macarons! Give us a call to find out about our monthly flavors!